Subjectivity & multiple solutions: call for conflict
This subjectivity and multiple solutions create conflict in design. If you are a designer and work with Product Managers you would have faced these kinds of debates. There would be occasions when you would land up in a situation where the design choices are even. Both have their own qualities. What do you do? Use reasoning of course. And to add to the complexity in designer’s life – every one can think about design. It’s something that every one encounters and thus they have ideas or opinions about it. Design is primarily thought driven than skill driven; and thus every one can think. The only differentiator for designer is the ‘awareness’ and his ability analyze more parameters than the untrained designers.
Trust
Thus a designer’s job isn’t only to provide design solutions; there is a lot that goes ‘behind the scene’. As a designer the first thing you want to do is build ‘respect’ and ‘trust’. Very often you would land us in these 50-50 choices; and here how much you team trust you makes a huge difference. Not every small decision can be tested with user thus you need to be responsible and careful with your design decisions. One error and you’ll lose you ‘veto’ power.
Moving to new team? You are back to zero
This could be one of the reasons why some designers don’t want to shift teams. Every time you move to another team you are back to ‘zero’. You again have to build your respect and trust. As design is subjective unlike mathematics or engineering so it becomes really difficult to prove your solutions.
I guess ‘design’ is all about ‘trust’ – trust in you decisions and trust in you by your team.
2 comments:
I heard this once - Design is subjective, even the office boy can comment, pull up your pant and explain. Take all the comments, sort the good from the bad and reuse. But then in design, too many cook spoils the broth. Its an everyday challenge that we designer live with :)
Yes design is complex. And because the solution depends on how 'u' look at the problem;I call design 'subjective'. Also there is no right or wrong solution in design. Any design solution has its pros and cons. Its all about 'judgment' (there is no golden formula).
Design needs discipline and clarity; doesn't depends on 'no. of cooks' (i feel).
Post a Comment